Saturday, 27 January 2018

The Fate of Rohingyas


Another happening in the world around us that really bothered me and intrigued me was the problem of the fleeing Rohingyas refugees. They are not just fleeing, but it is a mass exodus, them fleeing in thousands and tens of thousands.

In 2015 there was a major episode and the Rohingyas fled from Myanmar, a mass migration, when they fled to the South East Asian countries like Malaysia, Indonesia and Thailand by boats, giving them the nick name ‘the boat people.’ Around 25,000 of them fled and some 300 of them lost their lives in the waters, while crossing the Straits of Malacca and Andaman Sea.

Now again in October-December 2017, another mass exodus took place, almost 500,000 people left their homes to take shelter in the border town of Bangladesh, Cox Bazar on rickety boats and on foot.

Why is this happening? Why are they fleeing thus? Who is persecuting them and why? Such questions troubled me and I wanted to study the background of the whole matter. What I found was amazing. 

Rohingyas are a Muslim minority group living in the Buddhist majority state of Rakhine, formerly known as Arakan, in the North West Province of Myanmar, the former Burma. Since beginning Myanmar refused to acknowledge this ethnic group as their own. They were considered ‘stateless entities,’ people who had come as refugees from Bangladesh.

The Rohingyas had lived in Arakan area for almost 200 years, ever since British rule was established in Burma (now Myanmar). The British colonized Burma for almost hundred years, from 1824 to 1948. During that time, laborers from India were encouraged to migrate to Burma by the British to cultivate rice. Such migration happened just as any migration would occur depending on the availability of labor and livelihood. The British ruled Burma as a province of India. Such a migration was considered normal, rather encouraged.

British had promised a separate land to the Rohingyas, a Muslim National Area in exchange of their support for the World War II. While Rohingyas supported the British, the nationalists Burmese supported the Japanese, considered intruders by the British. After the war the Rohingyas were rewarded by the British with prestigious government posts, but were denied a free state. As elsewhere colonial politics played here too and even after hundreds of years a population is suffering due to that.  

However once Burma gained its independence from the British rule in 1948, close on heels of Indian independence, the Rohingyas demanded an autonomous province that was promised to them. But Myanmar, now independent, refused to acknowledge these people as their own and declared their migration to their land during British era as illegal. They were denied citizenship. By 1950s the army crushed all opposition from Rohingyas.

The Act of citizenship of Myanmar of 1948, and thereafter 1982, did not include Rohingyas as one of the 135 ethnic groups of the country that was listed. Ever since they had suffered discrimination, oppression, persecution and forceful eviction. After the military coup in 1962, troubles started. 1970s saw the first military crackdown on them, forcing them to flee.

The basic requirement of citizenship in Myanmar was that the concerned person should have the required proof that a family of theirs had been living in Myanmar prior to 1948. No such record was forthcoming for Rohingyas, because they were considered as migratory laborers and were never issued with any such citizenship.

When registration for citizenship was taken up in 1977, the army which was in power by that time, refused to enlist Rohingyas and they were declared as illegal immigrants. They were given identity cards as foreigners. Thus they were deprived of basic rights. They cannot vote, they had no free access to study, work or travel, marry, practice their religion, or to health services.  They cannot own property; restrictions were placed on them entering certain professions like medicine or law or run for office.

In 2012 fresh violence against Rohingyas started. The trigger was the alleged gang rape and killing of a Burmese woman by some Rohingyas and killing of 10 Burmese women by some Rakhines. Since then riots, burning of the villages of Rohingyas and blood shed have been the norm. The majority Rakhines also persecuted them. It was nothing but a virtual ethnic cleansing. Since 2012 Bangladesh had received some 200,000 Rohingyas as refugees who are living in Cox Bazar.

The recent violence against Rohingyas started in October 2017, when a few of Rohingya militants under the name Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army attacked some of the army stations, a very stupid idea. They are a Muslim militant group and the army suspects that they are trained by ISI of Pakistan and aided with money from Saudi Arabia.

In the military backlash that followed the poor and innocent Rohingyas paid the price. Their houses were torched, youth killed and they were forced to flee the country.  5,00,000 refugees landed in Cox Bazar due to this  2017. They are living in squalor and unhygienic conditions despite the United Nation’s humane services to these poor and displaced people.

Aug San Suu Kyi of Myanmar, it’s elected leader of National League for Democracy, and the winner of Nobel Peace Prize in 1991, and the present State Counsellor, which is a post akin to that of a Prime Minister of the nation, has maintained a stoic silence in the matter of military oppression of Rohingyas, despite international criticism.

The fear of the Myanmar government seems to be that this Muslim minority, a foreign body with a separatist agenda, might swell in the future and overcome the Buddhist majority population, and the country could become a Muslim spot on the world map, brewing up terrorist activities.

May be the way today’s Britain or the West might fear that the Muslim population will overtake them in biological numbers. Or as Qaddafi, while he was alive, said to have assured his fellow religious men, not to resort to terrorism to win the West, but they can do so by sheer numbers very soon.

Or even as some in authority in India worried that Tamil Nadu might want to separate from Indian Union, if joined together with the Tamils in the north east Sri Lanka. I am sure they heaved a sigh of relief when the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam of Sri Lanka lost and their leader Prabhakaran was killed in action.

Be that as it may, these are no justifications for a government to uproot and destroy an ethnic minority, especially the poor and the vulnerable who are caught in between. Any person born in a country has a claim to be counted as the citizen of that country, especially if parents were also born and lived in the country. To say that one has no citizenship even after generations of the family having lived in a country, is utter injustice. And this is what is happening to the Rohingyas in Myanmar.


International agencies and institutions will have to bring pressure on the government of Myanmar to be more humane and resolve this crisis in which the poor and the marginalized are bearing the brunt against an organized crime against humanity. A people cannot be treated as cattle, and neither could citizenship be denied to those who have lived in a country for generations. 

Saturday, 6 January 2018

Catalonia, What Ails Thee?!


First of all, let me wish you all a very happy New Year, 2018. It has been almost two months and more since I wrote last! Apologies, here after I promise to be more regular!

I have always been intrigued why Catalonia wants to separate from Spain and become independent. Usually a people who are suppressed, oppressed and undergone human right violations would want to separate from such abusers. But what of Catalonia? It is a developed county, doing very well economically, a rich part of Spain, why would they want to separate?

So I dug deep into their history to learn reasons for these recent developments. I was amazed to discover they have a long history and many historical developments starting from 8th century.

First, a few words about the place. Catalonia is situated in the north east border of Spain and France. It has a population of 75 million people and 95% of them are Catalan people. Theirs is a prosperous region with highly successful cities like Barcelona, which is also a port.

The Moors, the Muslims invaded and conquered Iberian Peninsula, consisting of today’s Spain and Portugal, in 711 AD. Christian reconquest along the north and eastern coastline began by Franks. Catalan county became the buffer zone between the Christian and Muslim territory known as Marpa Hispanica.

By 9th century County of Barcelona, a teeming city in Catalan was formed by the efforts of Charlemagne to establish a buffer zone between his Frankish Empire and the Muslim ruled Spain.

In 1131 Ramon Berenguer IV, the Count of Barcelona married Queen Patroilla of Aragon, which united the county with the kingdom of Aragon, but Catalan kept its own trade rights and parliament assuring it’s self rule. Catalan flourished. In 1469 Ferdinand I of Aragon and Queen Isabella of Castile married uniting their kingdoms to form the Kingdom of Spain.

When Christopher Columbus discovered the Americas in 1492 and trade shifted from Mediterranean Sea to Atlantic Sea, Catalan’s fortunes dipped a little. In Reaper’s war in 1640-52, Catalan revolted against the tax policies of Philip IV, king of Spain and declared a republic, with French protection, but was reoccupied by the Spanish troops. So the problem started very much in 17th century itself.

In the War of Succession of Spanish throne in 1704-14, Catalan supported the rival claimant to the crown, Archduke Charles of Austria of the House of Hapsburg, against King Philip V of the House of Bourbon. When Philip became the king, he took revenge and suppressed Catalan’s rights to independent parliament and trade liberties. Spanish language and laws were imposed on them.

In 1716, decrees were issued dismantling the separate Catalan legal system and bringing it under the direct rule of Madrid, Spain. The administrative use of Catalan language also was abolished.

Napoleon briefly occupied Catalan in 1812-13, and the first Carlist war took place in Catalan during 1808-1833. By the end of 19th century Catalan speedily industrialized herself and became a rich county and started to experience a cultural renaissance within Spain. Catalan nationalism started to rise too.

In 1931 Spain became a republic and Catalan also was proclaimed as a republic. After negotiations Catalan accepted autonomy within the Spanish State and an autonomous Catalan regional government was created. Modern politics of Catalonia starts from this point onward.

Unfortunately in the Spanish civil war that ensued in 1936, General Francisco Franco came to power and he abolished Catalan autonomy. During his dictatorship extending up to his death in 1975, Catalan was suppressed culturally and administratively.

After 1975, Spain became a democracy and Catalan as granted autonomy, regional government and its own police force and control over its educational system. The political parties in Catalan concentrated on obtaining autonomy rather than independence. But, demands for full independence started to arise in Catalan very soon.

In 2006 the autonomy agreement granted Catalonia the status of a nation within Spain with tax raising powers.  From 2009 to 2011, 550 municipalities in Catalonia voted in favor of the referendum.

The Supreme Court in 2010 ruled that some of the articles of the 2006 Statute of Autonomy were unconstitutional. This sparked off fresh demands for independence and protest erupted all over Catalan region.

In snap elections held in 2012, a pro-independent party won majority and formed government. In 2013, Catalan sovereignty was declared and it was given the freedom to decide its own political future. In 2014 when Catalan government wanted to become independent and conduct a referendum, the Spanish government referred it to the Supreme Court, which turned it down as unconstitutional.

Thereafter the situation steadily declined. On 1 October 2017 a fresh referendum on independence was conducted and 90% of the people said yes to independence. 43% was the turn out. Spain in Madrid wouldn’t accept even conduct of this referendum and sent its police force to prevent it from happening. The excesses of police forces during this referendum tilted the scales. Even those who did not seek separation from Spain wanted to separate now.

On 27.10.2017, when Catalan declared independence, President Mariano Rajoy took direct control of Catalonia, as per Article 155 of the Spanish Constitution. Catalan leaders were arrested for sedition and its President, Carles Puigdemont fled to Belgium. Snap regional poles were ordered on 21.12.2018. The pro-independence parties won majority, albeit narrowly.

Whatever is the outcome of the present embroiligo, it is seen that Catalonia has had a long history of wrestling for independence and compromising for a regional autonomy within the country Spain. Now why is this so?

Apart from having their own language, customs, education, self-rule and such privileges, Catalonia is also a rich region. Economically, 25.6% of exports from Spain are contributed by Catalonia. It contributes to 19% of Spain’s GDP. It accounts for 20% of Spain’s foreign investment. It is a significant part of Spain and Spain cannot afford to lose it.

However, Catalan pays more tax to Madrid, than the other regions, and its riches go to subsidize the poorer regions in Spain. Catalans are tired of subsidizing practically the rest of Spain, while they hardly get equivalent budgetary support from Madrid. No major infrastructural projects have been taken in Catalonia in spite of need. Hence they want to manage their own finances and development, without financially supporting the country, Spain.

Unfortunately, Spain is also one of the few countries, along with Greece, Portugal and Ireland, heavily indebted to European Union, which has imposed heavy austerity measures on the country. Catalans also suffer under these austerity measures and they feel they can manage their affairs better without having to bear the burden of the whole country. In short they want to control their own economy.

Well, what will happen next? No one, especially in European Union wants Spain to be split up. It might trigger similar demands all over Europe.

May be Catalonia will settle down if more fiscal autonomy is granted within the Spanish Constitution, along with political autonomy.


Let’s hope for the best.