Tuesday, 15 September 2015

Why didn’t God accept Cain’s Sacrifice?



In my previous blog on Cain I was concentrating on where and how he found his wife, and that there were no other people or race other than the descendants of Adam and Eve on earth. I didn't delve into why Cain’s sacrifice was not accepted.  Some have raised this point and it is quite a valid doubt too. In this blog I will try and address this issue.

For clarifying such doubts we need to go back to Bible itself, the written word. In Genesis 4:7 (NKJV), prior to Cain killing his brother Abel, God tells Cain, 'If you do well, will you not be accepted? "This hints that Cain didn't do well. In what manner he didn't do well, we are not given. It is definitely not because Cain didn't offer animal sacrifice, as some people interpret. It might not be also because he didn't do it with a clean heart. He didn't do well something, which God had prescribed. We can only guess at this juncture. It could be a rule, a procedure or method of offering the sacrifice. NIV translates this verse as 'If you do what is right, will you not be accepted?' Again it is clear that Cain didn't do something 'right.' What is it, we do not know exactly, but we can presume what it could be, based on similar passages elsewhere in the Bible. 

In another place in the Biblical narrative, it is written that God struck down dead Uzzah, who touched the Ark of the Covenant, which was being transported in a bullock cart. When the oxen stumbled, he put his hands to steady the Ark, and in the process he touched the Ark. God killed him off in an instant. Why? Because God had prescribed a method by which Ark should be transported - only by two long poles placed on the shoulder of the Levites. The Ark had four rings of gold on its four corners. Two poles were made, overlaid with gold, and the commandment was “You shall put the poles into the rings on the sides of the ark, that the ark may be carried by them.” Exodus 25:14. The poles were not to be removed from the ark at any time. The ark was important because in it were laid the Ten Commandments, carved on the two tablets of stone, the Testament. On the top of the Ark was the Mercy Seat made of pure gold. And that is from where God of Israel met His people, including Moses. Hence the Ark was most holy and was placed in the Most Holy chamber of the Tabernacle or the Temple.

While transporting the Ark, David committed the mistake of carrying it in a cart. The next time it was being transported, David did according to the prescribed procedure, and no one was hurt. (see 2 Samuel 6:3-7, 12-13). If you apply this analogy, Cain might have done something wrong in the way he offered his sacrifice. Definitely, if he had waited and corrected his method, his sacrifice also would have been accepted, for God says in Genesis 4:7, 'If you do well, will you not be accepted?' Cain didn't have the patience, but acted hastily, taking the law into his own hands.

Again see Hebrew 11:4, where it is said, 'By faith Abel offered to God a more excellent sacrifice than Cain,...' (NKJV) In what way it was excellent, we do not know. NIV puts it as 'By faith Abel offered God a better sacrifice than Cain did, ...' Better sacrifice, because of the animal sacrifice which Abel offered or because his attitude was better and more acceptable, we do not know. We can only presume. It was what Abel believed and not what he offered that must have made the difference. Or may be, it is just that Abel offered the sacrifice in the manner prescribed, in the manner it was acceptable to God. The real meaning is hidden, but we can always guess and take a stand according to Biblical study of similar passages, incidents and by consulting a few translations. The Holy Spirit will always enlighten us as to the truth. 

The other doubt is, Cain could have committed the murder at the spur of the moment and that it was not a premeditated offence. Genesis 4:5 tells us that Cain was very angry and his face fell, when his offering was not accepted by God. On observing his fallen face, God warns him not to brood over it thus, because it is sin and it will overpower him. In Genesis 4:7, He says, “If you do well, will you not be accepted? And if you do not do well, sin lies at the door. And its desire is for you, but you should rule over it.” Cain was definitely contemplating what to do to avenge himself. He was jealous and angry. It led him astray. Next verse says that Cain talked with Abel and when they were together in the field, he rose against his brother Abel and killed him. This does not appear as done on the spur of the moment. He talked with his brother, still he couldn't contain himself, he was burning with jealousy, and he rose against Abel and killed him. When you ruminate a matter in your mind for long, some action plan develops in your mind and you act accordingly. This is what Jesus meant in Matthew 5:28, when he said, even if you look at a woman lustfully, you have committed adultery. Thinking leads to a plan and action follows. That is why God warned Cain to overcome his wrong thinking, the sin, before it could overpower him. But Cain let the sin overpower him. 

We cannot say that God wanted Cain to kill Abel and so He created such a scenario. Why would God do that? Even if He did, what did he get out of it? What was the benefit to Him or to mankind? Nothing. God warns Cain because God knew what was in Cain's mind and warns him that he must overpower the sin that is crouching at his doorstep. God knows everything, past, present and future. But He has given human beings free will to make our own choices. We cannot blame God for the decisions we make and the consequences we suffer because of our decisions. God warns us, but if we do not heed it, but go ahead and commit mistakes and even horrible sins like murder, we cannot blame God for it. God never tempts us or makes us do wrong things. James 1:13-15. He never asked Eve to eat the forbidden apple, but warned them not to touch it. But she went ahead; they ate it, and reaped the consequences.

However, God being merciful does not punish us as we should be. He only cursed Cain to be a vagabond on the face of the earth. Even there, when Cain cried out saying it is a heavy punishment, God comes to his rescue, by putting a sign on him, so that others won't kill him. Moreover, God makes "all things work together for good to those who love God, ..." Romans 8:28, and God brings good out of the mess we make in this world of His. So we can never blame God thus. Our God is not that type of a god, who pinches the baby and rock the cradle. He is trustworthy, fair, just and merciful. It is His character that we put our trust in and not anything else. He is our Rock. 




No comments:

Post a Comment